Pelletgrill& Smoker

Recipes

Reverse Sear Steak on a Pellet Grill

Edge-to-edge pink with a hard crust, and the one steak method that plays to a pellet grill's strengths instead of fighting its weaknesses.

By Mike M. · Last updated November 13, 2026 · How we pick

Use a steak at least 1.5 inches thick. Smoke at 225°F until the center reads 115–120°F, then sear at maximum heat for 60–90 seconds a side. Medium-rare finishes at 130–135°F.

Jump to the recipe ↓

Why this method suits a pellet grill

Pellet grills are excellent at holding a low temperature and, compared with a gas grill or a cast iron pan, mediocre at searing. Reverse searing asks the grill to do the thing it is good at for 95% of the cook, then needs raw heat for ninety seconds at the end.

It also makes the smoke count. A steak seared first and finished hot never spends time in the range where it absorbs smoke. This way it sits at 225°F for most of an hour, picking up flavor you cannot get from a pan.

Cooked steak resting on a wooden chopping board

At a glance

Prep time
10 minutes
Cook time
40-60 minutes, depending on thickness
Smoker temp
225°F, then maximum heat to sear
Target internal temp
Pull at 115-120°F, sear to 130-135°F
Pellet flavor
Oak, hickory or mesquite
Serves
2 servings

Thickness is the whole prerequisite

Below about an inch and a half there is no point. A thin steak reaches its target temperature in minutes, so there is no slow stage to speak of and no time for smoke, and the sear alone will take it past medium. Buy one thick steak and split it rather than two thin ones.

Reverse Sear Steak

Ingredients

  • 2 thick-cut steaks, at least 1.5 inches (ribeye, strip or sirloin)
  • 2 tsp kosher salt
  • 2 tsp coarse black pepper
  • 1 tbsp high-smoke-point oil, for the sear
  • 2 tbsp butter and a garlic clove, optional, for basting

Method

  1. 1Use a thick steak

    Reverse searing needs at least an inch and a half of thickness. A thin steak hits its target temperature before it ever picks up smoke, and there is nothing for the method to improve.

  2. 2Season and smoke at 225°F

    Salt and pepper both sides, then smoke at 225°F until the center reads 115-120°F for a medium-rare finish. That is usually 40 to 60 minutes.

  3. 3Rest while the grill heats

    Take the steaks off and set the grill to its maximum. Open the sear slider if yours has one. The steaks resting for 10 minutes here is useful, not wasted time.

  4. 4Sear hard and fast

    Oil the steaks lightly and sear for 60-90 seconds a side, no longer. The surface is already dry from the smoking stage, so the crust forms quickly. Baste with butter and garlic in the last 30 seconds if you like.

  5. 5Check and serve

    Medium-rare lands at 130-135°F after the sear. Serve straight away — the steak has already had its rest, and waiting now just lets it cool.

Reverse sear targets for a 1.5 inch steak.
DonenessPull from smoke atAfter searing
Rare105-110°F120-125°F
Medium-rare115-120°F130-135°F
Medium125-130°F140-145°F
Medium-well135-140°F150-155°F

Times are a planning guide, not a timer. Every cut stalls differently, so cook to internal temperature and treat the clock as a rough estimate.

Gear for this cook

The limiting factor here is maximum grate temperature. If your grill tops out below 450°F, finish the sear in a cast iron pan — see our sear kits page.

#ad Those pages carry affiliate links and live prices — how this site is funded.

Cook this next

Questions people actually ask

How thick should a steak be for reverse searing?

At least 1.5 inches, and 2 inches is better. Thinner steaks reach their target temperature before they can pick up smoke, and the sear alone overcooks them.

What temperature do you smoke a steak to before searing?

115–120°F for a medium-rare finish. Searing adds roughly 10–15°F, bringing it to 130–135°F.

Do you rest a steak after a reverse sear?

Barely. The rest happens between the smoke stage and the sear, so the steak can go straight to the plate afterwards. A minute or two is plenty.

Sources