Pelletgrill& Smoker

Covers & Accessories

Butcher Paper and Foil for Smoking

The wrap decides your bark. Paper breathes and keeps it firm; foil traps steam and softens it — and both are correct answers to different questions.

By Mike M. · Last updated November 13, 2026 · How we pick

Best for Wrapping

Bryco Goods Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 100 ft)

Bryco Goods Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 100 ft)

Bryco Goods · Wrapping a brisket and keeping the bark

Food-grade, unbleached and made in the USA, in the 18-inch width that wraps a brisket without a seam.

Quick picks

Prices are live from Amazon as of November 18, 2026 — tap a price to check it now.

Butcher Paper and Foil for Smoking — ranked, with live Amazon prices.
#ProductBest forPrice
1
Bryco Goods Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 100 ft)
Bryco Goods Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 100 ft)

Bryco Goods

Food-grade, unbleached and made in the USA, in the 18-inch width that wraps a brisket without a seam.

Wrapping a brisket and keeping the bark$9.99Amazon
2
PerkHomy Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 200 ft)
PerkHomy Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 200 ft)

PerkHomy

Twice the roll for a couple of dollars more, which is the right maths if you smoke regularly.

Regular smokers who get through paper$14.98Amazon
3
Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Foil (18 in)
Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Foil (18 in)

Reynolds

The extra-wide heavy duty roll, which is what the Texas crutch actually needs — standard foil tears on a bone.

Wrapping ribs and anything with bones$10.17Amazon

#ad We earn a commission on purchases made through these links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes the ranking — here is the method.

Use pink butcher paper for brisket, where bark matters most — it breathes slightly, so it pushes you through the stall without steaming the crust soft. Use heavy duty foil for ribs and anything with bones, where speed and moisture matter more than crust. Buy 18-inch width either way.

What the wrap is actually for

Between roughly 150°F and 170°F a large cut stops climbing in temperature, sometimes for hours. That is the stall, and it is evaporative cooling — moisture leaving the surface carries heat away as fast as the grill delivers it. Wrapping stops the evaporation, which is why the temperature starts moving again. The technique is called the Texas crutch.

Paper versus foil

What each wrap does, and when to use it.
Pink butcher paperHeavy duty foil
BreathabilitySlightly porousCompletely sealed
Effect on barkStays firmSoftens noticeably
Speed through the stallFastFastest
Risk of pot-roast textureLowHigher if overdone
Tears on bonesYes, if handled roughlyOnly if standard-gauge
Best forBrisket, pork shoulderRibs, and recovering a late cook

Why 18 inches

A full packer brisket needs to be wrapped in one sheet with a decent overlap. Anything narrower means seams, and seams leak. Eighteen inches is the standard width for exactly this reason, and it also covers a full rack of ribs without joining two pieces.

On length: a 100 ft roll is plenty for occasional cooking, but a 200 ft roll is usually only a couple of dollars more and works out at the lowest cost per foot. If you smoke most weekends, buy the long one.

It must be unbleached, uncoated, food-grade butcher paper. Pink or peach butcher paper is sold specifically for this. Do not substitute craft paper, parchment or wax-coated paper — coatings are not meant to be heated against food, and craft paper is not food grade.

Standard foil will not do

Regular-gauge foil punctures on a rib bone almost every time, and a punctured wrap leaks its liquid into the grill and loses the point of wrapping. Heavy duty, 18 inches wide, is the specification that works. It costs very little more.

Where each one goes

Paper on brisket, where our method wraps at 165–170°F once the bark has set. Foil on 3-2-1 ribs, where the entire middle stage is a deliberate two-hour steam. Either on pulled pork, which is forgiving enough not to care much.

The picks in full

#1 · Wrapping a brisket and keeping the bark

Bryco Goods Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 100 ft)

Bryco Goods

Bryco Goods Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 100 ft)

Food-grade, unbleached and made in the USA, in the 18-inch width that wraps a brisket without a seam.

  • 18 in x 100 ft
  • Food grade, unbleached, uncoated
  • Made in USA

Good

  • 18 in is wide enough for a packer brisket in one wrap
  • Unbleached and uncoated, so nothing transfers to the meat

Trade-off

  • 100 ft goes quickly if you wrap most weekends

#2 · Regular smokers who get through paper

PerkHomy Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 200 ft)

PerkHomy

PerkHomy Pink Butcher Paper (18 in x 200 ft)

Twice the roll for a couple of dollars more, which is the right maths if you smoke regularly.

  • 18 in x 200 ft (2,400 in)
  • Unbleached
  • For smoking and resting

Good

  • The lowest cost per foot of the rolls we list
  • Same 18 in width as the shorter rolls

Trade-off

  • A long roll needs somewhere dry to live

#3 · Wrapping ribs and anything with bones

Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Foil (18 in)

Reynolds

Reynolds Wrap Heavy Duty Foil (18 in)

The extra-wide heavy duty roll, which is what the Texas crutch actually needs — standard foil tears on a bone.

  • 18 in width, 75 sq ft
  • Heavy duty gauge
  • Extra-wide

Good

  • Thick enough not to puncture on a rib bone
  • 18 in wraps a full rack without a seam

Trade-off

  • Softens bark in a way butcher paper does not

Questions people actually ask

Butcher paper or foil for brisket?

Butcher paper. It lets a little moisture escape, so you get through the stall without steaming the bark soft. Foil is faster but noticeably softens the crust.

Can I use regular parchment or craft paper instead?

No. It has to be unbleached, uncoated, food-grade butcher paper. Parchment is coated, and craft paper is not food grade.

What width butcher paper do I need?

Eighteen inches. That wraps a full packer brisket or a rack of ribs in a single sheet, and seams are where a wrap leaks.

Does wrapping make barbecue better?

It makes it faster and more predictable, and it protects the exterior while the center finishes. Unwrapped gives the best bark if you have the hours to spare. Both are legitimate; wrapping is simply the more reliable of the two.

Sources

Brands: want your product tested? For Brands.